Wilfried Nancy’s final match in charge of Celtic resulted in a home defeat against Rangers.
In the wake of a managerial departure, the immediate inclination is to dissect the downfall, tracing the critical missteps and identifying the moments when the outcome became inevitable.
However, in the case of Wilfried Nancy, such an analysis is unnecessary, as the appointment itself was fundamentally flawed from the outset. There were no pivotal turning points or plot twists in this ill-fated tenure.
Celtic’s decision to appoint Nancy ranks among the club’s most significant errors in recent history. A relatively inexperienced manager with a mediocre track record at Columbus Crew – who finished seventh in Major League Soccer – it was a gamble predicated on little more than the unconventional preferences of Paul Tisdale, the now-departed head of football operations.
During his brief but impactful tenure at Celtic Park, Tisdale remained largely silent to fans and media alike, yet he inflicted considerable damage. While Nancy’s appointment represents a significant blunder, Tisdale’s role in championing him to the club’s board arguably places him on par, if not slightly ahead, in terms of culpability.
Nancy’s reign never gained traction, with his only two victories in eight matches coming against a struggling Livingston side and a 10-man Aberdeen team, who have also recently dismissed their manager.
All recollections of Nancy’s tenure – if it can be called that – will now be conveniently forgotten by those responsible for his appointment. True to form, none will offer an explanation, an apology, or demonstrate the humility to acknowledge their profound misjudgment.
Fans will likely be presented with a brief written statement, a dismissive gesture reminiscent of “let them eat cake.”
Nancy’s relaxed arrival – marked by a mere 15-minute conversation with Martin O’Neill before dismantling O’Neill’s efforts to stabilize the team – stood in stark contrast to his abrupt departure. O’Neill, as interim manager, ultimately outlasted Nancy.
Celtic sack manager Nancy after eight games
How Nancy’s calamitous 33-day reign unfolded at Celtic
The Frenchman spoke of grand visions and the need for patience, operating under the delusion that he had ample time to implement his plans. In his alternate reality, he suggested that winning wasn’t paramount while his “process” unfolded.
He urged observers to consider his past achievements as evidence of his capabilities. “Do your job,” he challenged journalists, just a day before failing to do his own in a 3-1 home defeat to Rangers, following a 2-0 loss to Motherwell.
The departures of Nancy and Tisdale were necessary, but the underlying issues at the club extend far beyond these two individuals. The focus must shift to those who approved their appointments and the reasons behind those decisions. Celtic’s decline extends beyond the field, impacting the club’s overall management and leadership.
Since the start of the year, Celtic have lost a manager, a head of football operations, and a chairman (Peter Lawwell, who was forced out due to abusive behavior from a segment of the fanbase).
The club’s lack of communication is striking. Beyond the vocal minority, the vast majority of regular fans feel disconnected and alienated from the club’s direction.
While some may exhibit a sense of entitlement, and it’s easy to mock that considering Celtic’s past successes, many fans are simply frustrated with a club that is drifting, making poor decisions, and regressing both domestically and in Europe, despite holding nearly £80 million in the bank.
These fans express concerns about a lack of ambition and a clear plan under the current board, led by chief executive Michael Nicholson and major shareholder Dermot Desmond, as well as the influential figures operating behind the scenes.
Celtic’s vision appears limited to maintaining their lead over Rangers and achieving modest success in European competitions.
Brendan Rodgers challenged this narrow thinking, leading to a breakdown in his relationship with the club’s powerbrokers. His departure was marked by callousness and harsh words from Desmond, which Rodgers, despite any shortcomings, did not deserve.
His assistant manager, John Kennedy, also left at that time. Kennedy had dedicated 27 years to Celtic as both a player and coach, yet his departure was acknowledged with only a brief mention in a statement. He deserved better. The question arises: where is the dignity and respect?
Celtic lacks a comprehensive long-term vision, or at least one that is readily apparent. The club could expand its stadium to create a near-80,000-capacity fortress, among the best in Europe, but has not done so.
They could establish a world-class football museum, showcasing the club’s rich history and iconic moments, but there are no signs of such a project.
They could implement a modern and effective scouting system, but have not done so either.
Instead, they continue to operate with a parochial focus, content with domestic dominance, but even that is now under threat. The rise of Hearts, supported by Tony Bloom and Jamestown Analytics, poses a significant challenge to the established order.
Celtic believed they could afford to gamble on Nancy, confident that no other team could rival their control over the league title, their primary source of revenue.
As a result, they have reverted to the past, appointing O’Neill as interim manager until the end of the season. This decision makes sense, as O’Neill will provide structure and stability on the field.
The Celtic players should no longer appear bewildered or suffer sleepless nights due to tactical complexities. His return should energize the team, but the fact that the board has had to turn to him again underscores their own failings.
On Monday, the board corrected two mistakes that should never have been made, but the humiliation of the past few weeks and the season as a whole should prompt deep reflection among the leadership at Celtic Park. The fundamental question remains: Is this a truly great football club, or is it not?
Visit our Celtic page for all the latest news, analysis and fan views
Get Celtic news notifications in the BBC Sport app