Sir Paul McCartney’s performance at the Santa Barbara Bowl took an unexpected turn as the former Beatle instituted a temporary ban on phone usage, promising fans an exceptionally intimate concert experience.
The 4,500 attendees were required to secure their mobile phones in lockable pouches for the duration of the show, allowing them to fully immerse themselves in a “phone-free” environment.
“Nobody’s got a phone,” McCartney announced during his 25-song setlist. “Really, it’s better!” he added, emphasizing the benefits of undivided attention.
Implementing a large-scale phone ban involves a straightforward process.
Upon entering the venue, concertgoers place their phones into pouches that are then magnetically sealed.
Attendees retain possession of their phones, with the pouches unlocked via magnet at the conclusion of the performance.
Numerous artists, including Dave Chappelle, Alicia Keys, Guns N’ Roses, Childish Gambino, and Jack White, have embraced this concept, citing enhanced performance quality and increased creative freedom.
Sabrina Carpenter discussed the potential implementation of phone bans at her future concerts in a June interview with Rolling Stone.
The idea appears to be gaining traction among music enthusiasts.
Shannon Valdes, a fan who attended a Lane8 DJ set, shared on social media: “It was refreshing to be part of a crowd where everyone was fully present – dancing, connecting, and enjoying the best moments – rather than recording them.”
The creator of the pouch technology experienced his “Eureka” moment at a music festival in 2012.
“I saw a man drunk and dancing and a stranger filmed him and immediately posted it online,” Graham Dugoni explained. “It kind of shocked me.
“I wondered what the implications might be for him, but I also started questioning what our expectations of privacy should be in the modern world.”
Within two years, Dugoni, a 38-year-old former professional footballer, founded Yondr, a US-based startup advocating for phone-free environments.
While still in its infancy, the lockable pouch market is expanding, with new companies emerging. These pouches are increasingly utilized in theaters, art galleries, and educational institutions.
Prices range from £7 to £30 per pouch, contingent on the supplier and order size.
Yondr reports collaborations with approximately 2.2 million schools in America and states that around 250,000 children in England currently use its pouches across 500 schools – including one academy trust in Yorkshire which has invested £75,000 in Yondr pouches.
Paul Nugent, creator of Hush Pouch and a veteran of 20 years installing lockers in schools, highlights several factors for headteachers to consider.
“While it may seem like an expensive method for keeping phones out of schools, and some question why phones can’t simply remain in a student’s bag,” he explains.
“Smartphones generate anxiety, fixation, and FOMO – a fear of missing out. The only way to genuinely enable children to concentrate during lessons and enjoy break time is to lock them away.”
Dugoni of Yondr notes that school leaders have reported a range of positive outcomes from implementing phone-free policies.
“There have been notable improvements in academic performance, and headteachers also report reductions in bullying,” he explains.
Vale of York Academy in York introduced pouches in November, and headteacher Gillian Mills told the BBC: “It’s given us an extra level of confidence that students aren’t having their learning interrupted.
“We’re not seeing phone confiscations now, which took up time, or the arguments about handing phones over, but also teachers are saying that they are able to teach.”
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has stated her party would seek a complete ban on smartphones in schools should they assume office.
The Labour government has refrained from imposing a nationwide ban on smartphones in schools, deferring to headteachers’ discretion, but has launched a consultation on prohibiting social media for individuals under 16.
This is part of a larger initiative that will empower Ofsted, England’s education inspectorate, to assess phone usage policies during school inspections, with ministers anticipating schools to be “phone-free by default” as a result.
Nugent notes that the majority of parents feel their children are safer possessing a phone while traveling to and from school, as opposed to leaving it at home entirely.
“The first week or so after we install the system is a nightmare,” he adds. “Kids refuse, or try and break the pouches open. But once they realize no-one else has a phone, most of them embrace it as a kind of freedom.”
The ongoing expansion of social media platforms and AI directly challenges San Francisco’s tech giants and their algorithms, which are designed to promote constant smartphone usage.
However, Nugent believes a societal pushback is gaining traction.
“We’re getting so many enquiries now. People want to ban phones at weddings, in theatres, and even on film sets,” he says.
“Effectively carrying a computer around in your hand has many benefits, but smartphones also open us up to a lot of misdirection and misinformation.
“Enforcing a break, especially for young people, has so many positives, not least for their mental health.”
Dugoni concurs that we are approaching a critical juncture.
“We’re getting close to threatening the root of what makes us human, in terms of social interaction, critical thinking faculties, and developing the skills to operate in the modern world,” he explains.
“If we continue to outsource those, with this crutch in our pocket at all times, there is a danger we end up undermining what it means to be a productive person.
“And that is a moment where it’s worth pushing back and trying to understand where we go from here.”
Those 4,500 McCartney fans singing along to Hey Jude in the late September sunset might feel he has a point.
The singer hit out at Dr Zayn Khalid Majeed – who says he will try to have a positive impact with his content.
Independent Venue Week, which starts on Monday, aims to get more people watching grassroots gigs.
A girl, 16, explains how she “fell in love” with the pipes, while a boy, 14, says he loves the tunes.
Some 80,000 people are expected to attend the free three-day event in Sunderland in May.
The “music-visitors'” survey aims to build on excitement the “summer of Sabbath” generated in 2025.