Fri. Jan 9th, 2026
Ashes Squad Selection: Head, Stokes, or Starc? Experts Debate Key Picks

Do Travis Head (left), Ben Stokes (centre) and Mitchell Starc (right) merit selection in your XI?

With Australia having secured the Ashes, holding a 3-1 lead over England heading into the fifth Test, we ask: who makes your combined team of the series?

Performances from both sides have caught the eye, and we’re keen to know which players you’d select for a combined XI.

We’ve structured the selection process into four categories: openers, middle order (including all-rounders), wicketkeeper, and bowlers. Statistics, current up to the date of publication (January 4), are provided to inform your decisions.

The final XI will be revealed on the BBC Sport website, during The Ashes Debrief, and on the TMS podcast later in the Test.

Choose two players from the options below to be your opening batsmen.

Jake Weatherald: Innings: eight, runs: 146, average: 20.85, centuries: none

Travis Head: Innings: eight, runs: 437, average: 54.62, centuries: two

Zak Crawley: Innings: nine, runs: 272, average: 30.22, centuries: none

Ben Duckett: Innings: nine, runs: 160, average: 17.77, centuries: none

Select four players from the list below to fill positions three through six in your batting order.

Usman Khawaja: Innings: five, runs: 153, average: 30.60, centuries: none

Marnus Labuschagne: Innings: eight, runs: 174, average: 24.85, centuries: none

Steve Smith: Innings: six, runs: 136, average: 45.33, centuries: none

Cameron Green: Innings: six, runs: 112, average: 18.66; wickets: three, average: 71.66

Josh Inglis: Innings: three, runs: 65, average: 21.66, centuries: none

Ollie Pope: Innings: six, runs: 125, average: 20.83, centuries: none

Joe Root: Innings: nine, runs: 306, average: 43.71, centuries: one

Harry Brook: Innings: nine, runs: 310, average: 44.28, centuries: none

Ben Stokes: Innings: eight, runs: 183, average: 22.87, wickets: 13, average: 21.69

Will Jacks: Innings: five, runs: 118, average: 23.60, wickets: four, average: 61.50

Jacob Bethell: Innings: three, runs: 51, average: 17, centuries: none

Choose one player from the following to take the wicketkeeper’s position, batting at number seven.

Alex Carey: Innings: six, runs: 291, average: 48.50, dismissals: 25

Jamie Smith: Innings: eight, runs: 139, average: 19.85, dismissals: 13

Select four players from the options below to round out your team’s bowling attack, filling slots eight through eleven.

Mitchell Starc: Matches: five, wickets: 27, average: 18.74, strike-rate: 27.51; runs: 151

Scott Boland: Matches: five, wickets: 17, average: 24.47, strike-rate: 43

Pat Cummins: Matches: one, wickets: six, average: 19.50, strike-rate: 34

Brendan Doggett: Matches: two, wickets: seven, average: 30.71, strike-rate: 41.42

Michael Neser: Matches: three, wickets: 11, average: 20, strike-rate: 31.81

Nathan Lyon: Matches: two, wickets: five, average: 31.40, strike-rate: 66

Jhye Richardson: Matches: one, wickets: two, average: 15, strike-rate: 28

Jofra Archer: Matches: three, wickets: nine, average: 27.11, strike-rate: 53.33, runs: 102

Brydon Carse: Matches: five, wickets: 19, average: 25.57, strike-rate: 32.73

Gus Atkinson: Matches: three, wickets: six, average: 47.33, strike-rate: 73

Josh Tongue: Matches: three, wickets: 12, average: 18.58, strike-rate: 28.16

Mark Wood: Matches: one, wickets: none, average: N/A, strike-rate: N/A

Get cricket news sent straight to your phone

Comments can not be loaded

To load Comments you need to enable JavaScript in your browser